Rare Pennies

If you're looking to buy rare pennies, then you've come to the right place. Shop this awesome selection of rare pennies available for sale online. Browse our featured deals or look through our other rare coin. Start Shopping Now!

Rare Pennies on Ebay

1930 PENNY RARE AUSTRALIAN KING OF AUSSIE COINS & GENUINE
1930 PENNY RARE AUSTRALIAN KING OF AUSSIE COINS & GENUINE
$64,116.00 		Rare Very Light Strike 200? Penny Make Offer
Rare Very Light Strike 200? Penny Make Offer
$25,000.00 		1856 FLYING EAGLE PENNY PCGS MS63 RARE
1856 FLYING EAGLE PENNY PCGS MS63 RARE
$19,750.00
1968 LINCOLN PENNY DOUBLE STRIKE, VERY RARE
1968 LINCOLN PENNY DOUBLE STRIKE, VERY RARE
$18,650.00 		Very Rare 1924 LIGHTHOUSE Coin Op Strength Tester Penny Arcade *BEST OFFER* Rare
Very Rare 1924 LIGHTHOUSE Coin Op Strength Tester Penny Arcade *BEST OFFER* Rare
$12,995.00 		Penny Black (CJ) Plate 10 MINT Very Rare
Penny Black (CJ) Plate 10 MINT Very Rare
$10,748.76
RARE 1861 Indian Head Cent Penny BU UNC +++++ BIN OFFER
RARE 1861 Indian Head Cent Penny BU UNC +++++ BIN OFFER
$9,499.95 		RARE 1922 D WEAK D Lincoln Head Cent Penny BU BIN OFFER
RARE 1922 D WEAK D Lincoln Head Cent Penny BU BIN OFFER
$7,124.99 		ANFERNEE Penny HARDAWAY SUPER COLLECTION BASKETBALL CARD LOTs!RARE AUTO,HIGH ODD
ANFERNEE Penny HARDAWAY SUPER COLLECTION BASKETBALL CARD LOTs!RARE AUTO,HIGH ODD
$6,888.00
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1871 Indian Head Cent Penny BU UNC ++++ BUY IT NOW OR OFFER
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1871 Indian Head Cent Penny BU UNC ++++ BUY IT NOW OR OFFER
$6,595.60 		Vintage
Vintage "SUPERMAN" Coin op Penny Arcade strength tester All Original "VERY RARE
$6,000.00 		1922 NO D PENNY PCGS MS 62 RED WEAK REVERSE ***EXTREMELY RARE***
1922 NO D PENNY PCGS MS 62 RED WEAK REVERSE ***EXTREMELY RARE***
$6,500.00
1922 WEAK D PENNY NGC MS 64 RED BROWN WEAK D ***EXTREMELY RARE***
1922 WEAK D PENNY NGC MS 64 RED BROWN WEAK D ***EXTREMELY RARE***
$6,500.00 		FREE SHIPPING RARE 1909 S Indian Head Cent Penny BU UNC +++++ BUY IT NOW OFFER
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1909 S Indian Head Cent Penny BU UNC +++++ BUY IT NOW OFFER
$6,159.96 		1955 Double Die 1 cent Penny Mint State BN Very Rare
1955 Double Die 1 cent Penny Mint State BN Very Rare
$5,500.00
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1862 Indian Head Cent Penny BU UNC +++++ BUY IT NOW OR OFFER
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1862 Indian Head Cent Penny BU UNC +++++ BUY IT NOW OR OFFER
$4,950.00 		RARE 1857 Flying Eagle Cent Penny BU UNC ++++ BIN OFFER
RARE 1857 Flying Eagle Cent Penny BU UNC ++++ BIN OFFER
$4,250.00 		RARE 1859 Indian Head Cent Penny BU UNC +++++ BIN OFFER
RARE 1859 Indian Head Cent Penny BU UNC +++++ BIN OFFER
$3,989.95
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1860 Indian Head Cent Penny BU UNC +++++ BUY IT NOW OR OFFER
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1860 Indian Head Cent Penny BU UNC +++++ BUY IT NOW OR OFFER
$3,960.00 		1953 LINCOLN PENNY NGC ***PROOF 69 RED*** BEAUTIFUL FINEST KNOWN*EXTREMELY RARE*
1953 LINCOLN PENNY NGC ***PROOF 69 RED*** BEAUTIFUL FINEST KNOWN*EXTREMELY RARE*
$3,850.00 		1967 RARE Lincoln Wheat Cent Penny error PEEL
1967 RARE Lincoln Wheat Cent Penny error PEEL
$3,700.00
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1859 Indian Head Cent Penny BU UNC +++++ BUY IT NOW OR OFFER
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1859 Indian Head Cent Penny BU UNC +++++ BUY IT NOW OR OFFER
$3,696.00 		1909-S VDB LINCOLN HEAD CENT PENNY PCGS MS65 MS 65 RARE
1909-S VDB LINCOLN HEAD CENT PENNY PCGS MS65 MS 65 RARE
$3,675.00 		1841 Great Britain Penny Proof - PCGS PR66BN - RARE POP 1 !!
1841 Great Britain Penny Proof - PCGS PR66BN - RARE POP 1 !!
$3,650.00
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1873 Indian Head Cent Penny PROOF BUY IT NOW OR MAKE OFFER
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1873 Indian Head Cent Penny PROOF BUY IT NOW OR MAKE OFFER
$3,562.50 		1877 Indian Head Penny Cent * Gem Brown Proof * Extremely Rare *
1877 Indian Head Penny Cent * Gem Brown Proof * Extremely Rare *
$3,499.00 		1909-S VDB LINCOLN HEAD CENT PENNY PCGS MS-64 RARE LOOK
1909-S VDB LINCOLN HEAD CENT PENNY PCGS MS-64 RARE LOOK
$3,400.00
FREE SHIPPING VERY RARE 1800/79 LARGE CENT PENNY COIN XF BUY IT NOW OR OFFER
FREE SHIPPING VERY RARE 1800/79 LARGE CENT PENNY COIN XF BUY IT NOW OR OFFER
$3,419.95 		Penny Preville Diamond Halo Asscher Center Dangle Earrings 18K 1.02 cttw. Rare
Penny Preville Diamond Halo Asscher Center Dangle Earrings 18K 1.02 cttw. Rare
$3,300.00 		1880 INDIAN HEAD PENNY VERY RARE PCGS MS *65 RED* OLD GREEN HOLDER POPULTN 47/16
1880 INDIAN HEAD PENNY VERY RARE PCGS MS *65 RED* OLD GREEN HOLDER POPULTN 47/16
$3,200.00
1909-S VDB LINCOLN HEAD CENT PENNY PCGS MS64 MS 64 RARE
1909-S VDB LINCOLN HEAD CENT PENNY PCGS MS64 MS 64 RARE
$3,149.88 		Rare Penny 1955/55 Lincoln Cent MINT STATE 61 BN THATS RIGHT 1955 OVER 1955
Rare Penny 1955/55 Lincoln Cent MINT STATE 61 BN THATS RIGHT 1955 OVER 1955
$3,100.00 		1841 Penny Red (KF) Plate 8 Mint very rare
1841 Penny Red (KF) Plate 8 Mint very rare
$3,034.94
1947 1C LINCOLN WHEAT CENT PENNY NGC MS67 RED FINEST REGISTRY RARE ★
1947 1C LINCOLN WHEAT CENT PENNY NGC MS67 RED FINEST REGISTRY RARE ★
$2,995.00 		1877 Indian Head Penny Cent * Choice AU * Extremely Rare * Price Reduced *
1877 Indian Head Penny Cent * Choice AU * Extremely Rare * Price Reduced *
$2,650.00 		The Clash
The Clash "Sandinista" Rare Poster+Clash Signed Pennie Smith Photograph
$2,500.00
Outstanding Rare 1940's Exhibit Card Penny Arcade Vending Machine
Outstanding Rare 1940's Exhibit Card Penny Arcade Vending Machine
$2,495.00 		RARE 1641 St Patrick Half Penny COLONIAL COIN TOKEN
RARE 1641 St Patrick Half Penny COLONIAL COIN TOKEN
$2,500.00 		1914-D Weak D Lincoln Cent Penny Extremely Rare Variety! Error
1914-D Weak D Lincoln Cent Penny Extremely Rare Variety! Error
$2,500.00
1923 HALF PENNY RARE AUSTRALIAN COIN & GENUINE
1923 HALF PENNY RARE AUSTRALIAN COIN & GENUINE
$2,367.36 		1883 INDIAN HEAD PENNY VERY RARE OLD GREEN RATTLER PCGS PROOF 65 RED UNDERGRADE?
1883 INDIAN HEAD PENNY VERY RARE OLD GREEN RATTLER PCGS PROOF 65 RED UNDERGRADE?
$2,400.00 		1873 INDIAN HEAD PENNY APPEALING VERY RARE BEAUTY DOUBLE DIE OBVERSE ANACS EF 45
1873 INDIAN HEAD PENNY APPEALING VERY RARE BEAUTY DOUBLE DIE OBVERSE ANACS EF 45
$2,400.00
Gibraltar 2000 Blue Penny Bimetal Titanium Gold Coin,Proof,Rare
Gibraltar 2000 Blue Penny Bimetal Titanium Gold Coin,Proof,Rare
$2,390.00 		RARE 1899 Indian Head Cent Penny BU UNC ++++ BIN OFFER
RARE 1899 Indian Head Cent Penny BU UNC ++++ BIN OFFER
$2,339.10 		Extremely rare Silver Elizabeth I, Pledge Penny coin, 1601 , Genuine coin
Extremely rare Silver Elizabeth I, Pledge Penny coin, 1601 , Genuine coin
$2,212.98
1909 S V.D.B. LINCOLN WHEAT PENNY RARE KEY APPEALING BEAUTIFUL VERY HIGH QUALITY
1909 S V.D.B. LINCOLN WHEAT PENNY RARE KEY APPEALING BEAUTIFUL VERY HIGH QUALITY
$2,000.00 		RARE 1943 S OVER S LINCOLN STEEL PENNY BU MINT RARE ERROR COIN DOUBLED S
RARE 1943 S OVER S LINCOLN STEEL PENNY BU MINT RARE ERROR COIN DOUBLED S
$1,999.99 		RARE 1909 S VDB Lincoln Head Penny Cent UNC ++ BIN
RARE 1909 S VDB Lincoln Head Penny Cent UNC ++ BIN
$1,995.00
HAWAII RARE 1847 KAMEHAMEHA COPPER PENNY SELDOM SEEN
HAWAII RARE 1847 KAMEHAMEHA COPPER PENNY SELDOM SEEN
$1,950.00 		2009 LINCOLN CENT PENNY PROFESSIONAL LIFE FIRST DAY CEREMONY NGC MS68 RARE MS 68
2009 LINCOLN CENT PENNY PROFESSIONAL LIFE FIRST DAY CEREMONY NGC MS68 RARE MS 68
$1,950.00 		1877 Indian Head Penny Cent * PCGS VF30 * Extremely Rare *
1877 Indian Head Penny Cent * PCGS VF30 * Extremely Rare *
$1,895.00
Rare Penny 1922 Missing D Strong Reverse Die Pair 2 Lincoln Cent Anacs VF 30
Rare Penny 1922 Missing D Strong Reverse Die Pair 2 Lincoln Cent Anacs VF 30
$1,900.00 		FREE SHIPPING RARE 1922 NO D Lincoln Head Cent Penny VF-EF BUY IT NOW OR OFFER
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1922 NO D Lincoln Head Cent Penny VF-EF BUY IT NOW OR OFFER
$1,895.20 		1922 NO D LINCOLN WHEAT PENNY APPEALING HIGHER QUALITY RARE KEY DATE STRONG REVS
1922 NO D LINCOLN WHEAT PENNY APPEALING HIGHER QUALITY RARE KEY DATE STRONG REVS
$1,800.00
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1927 S Lincoln Head Penny Cent BU UNC ++++ BUY IT NOW OR OFFR
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1927 S Lincoln Head Penny Cent BU UNC ++++ BUY IT NOW OR OFFR
$1,750.00 		Penny Red Star (BE) C10 A06 Used in HONDURAS RARE
Penny Red Star (BE) C10 A06 Used in HONDURAS RARE
$1,707.16 		FREE SHIPPING RARE 1897 Indian Head Cent Penny PROOF BUY IT NOW OR MAKE OFFER
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1897 Indian Head Cent Penny PROOF BUY IT NOW OR MAKE OFFER
$1,671.96
ESTATE ANTIQUE 1877 RARE KEY DATE INDIAN HEAD CENT PENNY COIN COLLECTIBLE NEAT
ESTATE ANTIQUE 1877 RARE KEY DATE INDIAN HEAD CENT PENNY COIN COLLECTIBLE NEAT
$1,650.00 		1955 Double Die Obverse Lincoln Penny NGC AU Details!! VERY RARE Coin!
1955 Double Die Obverse Lincoln Penny NGC AU Details!! VERY RARE Coin!
$1,600.00 		RARE CNUT (CANUTE)[1017-23] PENNY QUATREFOIL TYPE LEOFWOLD ON NORTHAMPTON EF
RARE CNUT (CANUTE)[1017-23] PENNY QUATREFOIL TYPE LEOFWOLD ON NORTHAMPTON EF
$1,580.70
1841 Penny Red (EI/EL) Plate TWO (creased) Strip of Four Very RARE
1841 Penny Red (EI/EL) Plate TWO (creased) Strip of Four Very RARE
$1,517.47 		RARE ARCHBISHOP PLEGMUND DIARWALD HAMMERED ANGLO SAXON DORO PENNY COIN 023871
RARE ARCHBISHOP PLEGMUND DIARWALD HAMMERED ANGLO SAXON DORO PENNY COIN 023871
$1,501.67 		FREE SHIPPING RARE 1858 SL Flying Eagle Cent Penny BU UNC ++++ BUY IT NOW OFFER
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1858 SL Flying Eagle Cent Penny BU UNC ++++ BUY IT NOW OFFER
$1,535.60
1925 Australia Penny - Broken Leg N - gVF - 8 Pearls & Smooth - Very Rare
1925 Australia Penny - Broken Leg N - gVF - 8 Pearls & Smooth - Very Rare
$1,509.19 		Australian Penny 1925 PCGS XF45 rare
Australian Penny 1925 PCGS XF45 rare
$1,500.00 		AVC747 - 1944 LINCOLN WHEAT PENNY SPLIT PLANCHET PAIR NGC XF45 - RARE ERROR
AVC747 - 1944 LINCOLN WHEAT PENNY SPLIT PLANCHET PAIR NGC XF45 - RARE ERROR
$1,500.00
Rare Penny Arcade Amusement Park Coin Operated Crusader Horse Coin op Carnival
Rare Penny Arcade Amusement Park Coin Operated Crusader Horse Coin op Carnival
$1,500.00 		★SUPER RARE proof★ 1905 PR65RD Indian Head cent penny ★ONLY 2,152 minted!!!★
★SUPER RARE proof★ 1905 PR65RD Indian Head cent penny ★ONLY 2,152 minted!!!★
$1,499.99 		FREE SHIPPING RARE 1832 LL LARGE CENT PENNY COIN F-VF BUY IT NOW MAKE OFFER
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1832 LL LARGE CENT PENNY COIN F-VF BUY IT NOW MAKE OFFER
$1,499.95
RARE 1875 Indian Head Cent Penny PROOF BIN OFFERS
RARE 1875 Indian Head Cent Penny PROOF BIN OFFERS
$1,420.25 		1909-S VDB LINCOLN HEAD CENT PENNY PCGS VF-30 RARE LOOK
1909-S VDB LINCOLN HEAD CENT PENNY PCGS VF-30 RARE LOOK
$1,400.00 		1718 Rare Error Double Struck No Stop Obv. Britain US Colonial Geo I Half Penny
1718 Rare Error Double Struck No Stop Obv. Britain US Colonial Geo I Half Penny
$1,345.49
ANNE, PATTERN HALF PENNY, BMC 731, RARE
ANNE, PATTERN HALF PENNY, BMC 731, RARE
$1,343.60 		FREE SHIPPING RARE 1857 Flying Eagle Cent Penny BU UNC ++++ BUY IT NOW OR OFFER
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1857 Flying Eagle Cent Penny BU UNC ++++ BUY IT NOW OR OFFER
$1,276.00 		1861 Victoria Young Head Half Penny Half over Halp RARE
1861 Victoria Young Head Half Penny Half over Halp RARE
$1,250.00
Penny Warden Original Drawing Clarinet Rare
Penny Warden Original Drawing Clarinet Rare
$1,185.53 		1922 NO D PENNY NGC VF 25 BROWN STRONG REVERSE***EXTREMELY RARE***
1922 NO D PENNY NGC VF 25 BROWN STRONG REVERSE***EXTREMELY RARE***
$1,250.00 		1975 D LINCOLN PENNY STRUCK ON DIME PLANCHET EXTREMELY RARE HIGH QUALITY BEAUTY
1975 D LINCOLN PENNY STRUCK ON DIME PLANCHET EXTREMELY RARE HIGH QUALITY BEAUTY
$1,240.00
FREE SHIP RARE 1909 S Lincoln Head Penny Cent BU UNC +++++ BUY IT NOW OR OFFER
FREE SHIP RARE 1909 S Lincoln Head Penny Cent BU UNC +++++ BUY IT NOW OR OFFER
$1,235.00 		LINCOLN WHEAT PENNY 1922 NO D!!! RARE KEY MUST SEE
LINCOLN WHEAT PENNY 1922 NO D!!! RARE KEY MUST SEE
$1,200.00 		1864 Victoria Young Head Penny Plain
1864 Victoria Young Head Penny Plain "4" Super Rare
$1,150.00
1926 S LINCOLN WHEAT CENT PCGS MS63RB RARE UNCIRCULATED MS PENNY
1926 S LINCOLN WHEAT CENT PCGS MS63RB RARE UNCIRCULATED MS PENNY
$1,125.00 		Nike Air Foamposite One NRG Galaxy 2012 All Star DS NIB RARE size 8.5 Penny Glow
Nike Air Foamposite One NRG Galaxy 2012 All Star DS NIB RARE size 8.5 Penny Glow
$1,100.00 		AUSTRALIA 1956 PROOF PENNY - 1500 minted - FDC RED RARE
AUSTRALIA 1956 PROOF PENNY - 1500 minted - FDC RED RARE
$1,100.00
1699 HALF PENNY, PROOF IN SILVER, EXTREMELY RARE
1699 HALF PENNY, PROOF IN SILVER, EXTREMELY RARE
$1,027.46 		South Africa ZAR Penny 1892 NGC MS64BN RARE Grade!
South Africa ZAR Penny 1892 NGC MS64BN RARE Grade!
$999.00 		1932 Flat 2 Australia Penny - aUnc - 8 pearls - Extremely Rare Variety - A Must!
1932 Flat 2 Australia Penny - aUnc - 8 pearls - Extremely Rare Variety - A Must!
$1,006.13
15L14, 26 BLOOD'S PENNY POST TWO COVERS UNLISTED & RARE
15L14, 26 BLOOD'S PENNY POST TWO COVERS UNLISTED & RARE
$999.00 		Super Rare! Nike Air Foamposite One NRG Galaxy UK8/US9 Kanye Jordan Penny
Super Rare! Nike Air Foamposite One NRG Galaxy UK8/US9 Kanye Jordan Penny
$946.84 		South Africa WW2 Internment Camp 1 Penny Feller & Feller SA-1520 UNC RARE
South Africa WW2 Internment Camp 1 Penny Feller & Feller SA-1520 UNC RARE
$1,000.00
1909-S VDB LINCOLN HEAD CENT PENNY ANACS VF-30 RARE LOOK
1909-S VDB LINCOLN HEAD CENT PENNY ANACS VF-30 RARE LOOK "DIRT CHEAP"
$999.99 		rare error coin penny 4-i in liberty iliiiberty 1988 D
rare error coin penny 4-i in liberty iliiiberty 1988 D
$999.99 		1858/3 Victoria Young Head Penny
1858/3 Victoria Young Head Penny "SUPER RARE" S-3948
$975.00
★ 1894 South Africa Penny ICG MS64 - RARE BU Coin! ★
★ 1894 South Africa Penny ICG MS64 - RARE BU Coin! ★
$985.00 		1924-S High Grade Lincoln Penny Rare Key Date #2131
1924-S High Grade Lincoln Penny Rare Key Date #2131
$950.00 		1804 Draped Bust Large Cent S-266 Die State A Rare Key Date US Large Penny Coin
1804 Draped Bust Large Cent S-266 Die State A Rare Key Date US Large Penny Coin
$900.00
RARE 1862 Indian Head Cent Penny BU UNC +++++ BIN OFFER
RARE 1862 Indian Head Cent Penny BU UNC +++++ BIN OFFER
$899.95 		FREE SHIPPING RARE 1887 Indian Head Cent Penny Coin PROOF BUY IT NOW OR OFFER
FREE SHIPPING RARE 1887 Indian Head Cent Penny Coin PROOF BUY IT NOW OR OFFER
$879.96

Compare Prices For Rare Pennies on Amazon

Indian Head Cent / Penny Mixed Date Circulated Good or Better in Coin Flip
Indian Head Cent / Penny Mixed Date Circulated Good or Better in Coin Flip
$0.01 		Peeping Pawn
Peeping Pawn
$1.99 		Rev'd Up
Rev'd Up
$1.99
A Penny Saved
A Penny Saved
$1.99 		A Trick of the Light: A Chief Inspector Gamache Novel (Chief Inspector Gamache Novels)
A Trick of the Light: A Chief Inspector Gamache Novel (Chief Inspector Gamache Novels)
$14.12 		How To Play The Penny Whistle (Penny & Tin Whistle)
How To Play The Penny Whistle (Penny & Tin Whistle)
$7.99
River Phoenix~ River Phoenix Postcard~ Rare Postcard!!~ Approx 4
River Phoenix~ River Phoenix Postcard~ Rare Postcard!!~ Approx 4" x 6"
$6.02 		1937 Wheat US Copper One Cent Penny Coin Cufflinks
1937 Wheat US Copper One Cent Penny Coin Cufflinks
$29.99 		Dirge for a Dorset Druid: A Penny Spring and Sir Toby Glendower Mystery
Dirge for a Dorset Druid: A Penny Spring and Sir Toby Glendower Mystery
$20.00


Recent Searches

3 Wheat Penny Lincoln Cent Key Date Rare Usa Coins 1919, 1937, 1957 D No Reserve, Cheerios Lincoln Penny 2000 Mint Coin Philadelphia Millenium W Coa Rare Sealed, ★ 1919 Penny Obv Lamination Mint Error Awesome Rare Old Coin Lincoln Wheat Cent , 1957d Gem Bu Wheat Licoln Penny Cent Rare Collectable Coin Not Junk No Reserve, Rare Penniesnickels 20th Century , 1868 Indian Head Cent Early Key Date Copper Penny Full Liberty Rare Porous Coin, 1938 Vg Rare The Ugly Duckling Big Little Penny Book, 1938 Rare The Ugly Duckling Big Little Penny Book, Great Britain 1856 Rare Doubling Half Penny Extra Fine Almost Un Circulated, 1938 Rare F Little Polly Flinders Big Little Penny Book, Cute Tiny Fish Wood Mounted Rubber Stamp By Penny Black 1059a Rare, Bargain, Old, Rare, Us Coin A Large Us 1828 Penny , Disney Rare Brunette Penny Sweethearts American Girl Doll 18 New In Box, 1938 Rare F Hansel Grethel Big Little Penny Book, Disney Rare Blonde Penny Sweethearts American Girl Doll 18 New In Box, 1938 Nm Rare The Gingerbread Boy Big Little Penny Book ,